CSF Logo Contact Us
About Us Our Programs Animal Health Issues Information and Resource Links In The news

Discovery of BSE in Canada
• Up-to-date developments


Position Paper on the current BSE situation
May 22, 2003

Background
On May 20th, 2003, the Canadian Food Inspection Agency (CFIA) announced that Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy (BSE) was discovered in an eight-year old cow on a farm near Fairview, Alberta. Earlier in January, the cow was sent for slaughter where it was declared unfit for human consumption after exhibiting symptoms similar to pneumonia. It did not enter the human food chain and its remains were sent for rendering.

On May 16th, 2003 Alberta Agriculture, Food and Rural Development (AAFRD) tested the cow’s brain for BSE as part of its surveillance program. After preliminary test results indicated the presence of BSE, CFIA officials were notified. During the next two days extensive further testing was performed by CFIA and by experts in the United Kingdom. Test results from the UK were confirmed positive on May 20th, 2003.

The case farm was placed under quarantine on May 18th by CFIA. An investigation was initiated to trace the origin of the cow, its movement throughout its life, and the method in which its remains were processed. The remaining 150 cattle in the herd have been euthanized and are being tested for the presence of the disease. CFIA officials have also traced the movement of 211 calves from the original herd and have quarantined the feedlots where they were sent. The investigation is ongoing.

The investigation has shown that regulations governing the processing and rendering of the remains of the infected animal have been followed. CFIA officials maintain that Canadian beef products are safe and that the discovery of BSE in this cow poses little risk to human health.

Cause of BSE
BSE belongs to the family of Transmissible Spongiform Encephalopathies. It affects the central nervous system of cattle and is fatal. Although the onset of disease can take up to 8 years, animals degenerate quickly and usually die within a few months of exhibiting symptoms.

Although the cause of BSE is unknown, scientists believe that the disease is transmitted to cattle through meat and bone meal containing material from infected cattle. In 1997, Canada banned the feeding of rendered products from ruminants back to other ruminants (cattle, sheep, goats, deer and elk).

BSE has also been linked to its human counterpart, variant Creutzfeldt Jakob Disease (CJD).

Effects on International Trade
Canada, which was previously labelled "BSE - free" by international trade standards, is now considered "BSE - infected". This demotion in status has led the United States to impose a ban on all ruminants and ruminant products "pending further investigation". Other countries have followed including, Mexico, Japan, Australia, New Zealand and South Korea.

Effects of the BSE crisis on the Canadian Sheep Industry

Border Closing
The United States is the largest international market for Canadian sheep and lamb. In 2002, total exports of live sheep and processed product to the United States equaled approximately $19,800,000 (Statistics Canada). The current ban on all ruminants and ruminant products will, therefore, have a serious effect on our sheep industry over an extended period of time.

The Canadian Sheep Federation fundamentally disagrees with the inclusion of sheep and lamb under the ban. Industry representatives recognize that although scrapie in sheep is also a TSE, the scope of the current issue is limited to only BSE. Sheep do not transmit BSE to cattle or other ruminants, nor can they transmit scrapie to cattle through ruminant feed or other means. Furthermore, CFIA implemented a scrapie control program in 1945, which prohibits suspect infected animals from entering the human food chain. Scrapie, however, is not a human health risk. We feel confident, therefore, that Canadian sheep and lamb pose no risk to human health in the US and should be excluded from the current import ban.

Compensation
The border closing will result in the displacement of animals intended for export to the US. Many of these animals are raised to meet the US demand for heavy sheep and lambs and cannot be sold on the Canadian market. Furthermore, producers will suffer financial loss from the influx of animals on the Canadian market causing the prices to fall.

The Canadian Sheep Federation believes that sheep producers should be compensated by the government for any losses incurred as a result of the BSE crisis and the subsequent US import ban.

Media
The Canadian Sheep Federation recognizes that the domestic industry may also be harmed by media claims that scrapie in sheep causes BSE in cattle.

During the outbreak of BSE in the United Kingdom in the mid-1980s, scientist John Wilesmith theorized that the cattle contracted the disease by consuming meat and bone meal containing remains of sheep infected with scrapie. There was, however, no scientific evidence to support this theory and the British BSE Inquiry subsequently discounted it as "fallacious". Conclusive scientific evidence showed that BSE was transmitted to cattle through meat and bone meal infected with material from other cattle infected with the same disease. (British BSE Inquiry, Volume 1: Findings and Conclusions). This theory is still held today.

The Canadian Sheep Federation has designated Mr. Jonathan Wort, Chair of its Animal Health Committee and President of the Canadian Sheep Breeders Association, as the media spokesperson on the BSE issue to ensure the consistency and accuracy of information communicated to the public through the media. We believe that it is important to ensure that consumer perception of the quality and safety of Canadian sheep and lamb is not jeopardized by media attempts to link scrapie in sheep to BSE in cattle.

Support for the Canadian Cattle Industry
The Canadian Sheep Federation expresses its deepest support for the Canadian Cattlemen’s Association and members of the cattle industry in their struggle to overcome the current BSE crisis.

The Canadian beef industry has achieved domestic and international recognition for quality and safety, and continues to set standards that meet the highest expectations of consumers. We believe that it will remain the world’s leading supplier of beef and will continue to contribute significantly to Canada’s reputation as a world leader in agriculture.

 


Home Page